Does Social Media Do More Harm Than Good?
Weigh connection, creativity and free expression against anxiety, misinformation and addiction in one of the most debated questions of our time.
Pick a Side
Choose a position to defend, or let fate assign your stance.
Arguments FOR
1. It is linked to anxiety and depression in teens
Rising rates of teenage anxiety and depression coincide with smartphone and social media adoption, and the US Surgeon General issued a 2023 advisory on its risks.
2. Algorithms reward outrage and misinformation
Content that makes people angry spreads fastest, which fuels polarisation and lets false information outrun the truth.
3. It is designed to be addictive
Infinite scroll, notifications and likes exploit the brain's reward system, taking hours away from sleep, study and real friendships.
4. Cyberbullying follows children home
Online harassment reaches young people 24 hours a day, with no escape at home or school.
Arguments AGAINST
1. It connects people across distance
Families separated by migration, isolated people and minority groups find community and support online.
2. It gives everyone a voice
Social media has exposed injustice, organised protests and allowed ordinary people to challenge powerful institutions.
3. It creates jobs and opportunities
Small businesses, artists and creators reach customers and audiences without needing big companies or gatekeepers.
4. The problem is how it is used, not the tool
Teaching digital literacy and healthy habits is more effective than blaming the platforms for every social problem.
Counter Questions
Questions to challenge claims and probe deeper into trade-offs.
- Does social media cause teen mental health problems, or are struggling teens simply more likely to use it heavily?
- Should platforms be forced to switch off algorithmic feeds for under-18s?
- Would the Arab Spring or #MeToo have happened without social media?
- Is the harm caused by specific apps, such as image-based platforms, more than others?
- Who should be responsible for limiting screen time: parents, schools, governments or the platforms?
Ready to debate this topic?
Prepare your arguments and test your speech against the clock.