Should Popular Cities Limit the Number of Tourists?
Debate entry fees, caps and bans on holiday rentals in places like Venice, Barcelona and Kyoto that are overwhelmed by visitors.
Pick a Side
Choose a position to defend, or let fate assign your stance.
Arguments FOR
1. Residents are being priced out of their own cities
Short-term holiday rentals take homes off the market, pushing up rents until locals can no longer afford to live in historic centres.
2. Crowds damage heritage sites
Millions of visitors wear down monuments, streets and fragile ecosystems that took centuries to build.
3. Entry fees can fund maintenance
Venice introduced a fee for day-trippers in 2024, and such charges can pay for cleaning, conservation and local services.
4. Quality of life matters more than visitor numbers
Noise, litter and packed public transport make daily life miserable for people who live in tourist hotspots.
Arguments AGAINST
1. Tourism supports millions of jobs
Hotels, restaurants, shops and guides depend on visitors, and caps would destroy livelihoods.
2. Limits make travel a luxury for the rich
High fees and quotas mean only wealthy tourists can see world heritage sites.
3. Better management works better than bans
Timed tickets, spreading visitors to lesser-known areas and investment in infrastructure can handle crowds without turning people away.
4. Cultural exchange has value
Travel builds understanding between peoples, and closing the door undermines that.
Counter Questions
Questions to challenge claims and probe deeper into trade-offs.
- Should tourist taxes go directly to residents through lower rents or better services?
- Is it fair to ban holiday rentals that homeowners rely on for income?
- Do cruise ships deserve stricter limits than other tourists because they bring crowds but spend little?
- How can a city decide its maximum number of tourists?
- Is social media to blame for sending crowds to the same few photo spots?
Ready to debate this topic?
Prepare your arguments and test your speech against the clock.