Is War Ever Justified?
Debate pacifism against just war theory: can armed conflict ever be the morally right choice?
Pick a Side
Choose a position to defend, or let fate assign your stance.
Arguments FOR
1. Self-defence is a basic right
Nations, like individuals, have the right to defend themselves against invasion.
2. Some evils can only be stopped by force
The defeat of Nazi Germany in the Second World War is widely seen as justified.
3. Just war theory sets limits
Thinkers from Augustine to Aquinas argued war can be just with a just cause, right intention and as a last resort.
4. Failing to act can cost more lives
Critics argue the world's failure to intervene in the 1994 Rwandan genocide allowed mass killing.
Arguments AGAINST
1. War always kills innocent people
Even "precise" modern wars cause large numbers of civilian deaths and refugees.
2. Non-violence can succeed
Movements led by Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr. achieved major change without war.
3. Justifications are often false
Wars have been launched on claims, such as weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, that turned out to be wrong.
4. War creates cycles of violence
Conflicts leave bitterness and instability that can lead to future wars.
Counter Questions
Questions to challenge claims and probe deeper into trade-offs.
- Was the Second World War a just war for every country that fought in it?
- Is it ever justified to start a war to prevent a future attack?
- Should countries intervene militarily to stop genocide in other nations?
- Can nuclear weapons ever be used justly?
- Would a world without armies be safer or more dangerous?
Ready to debate this topic?
Prepare your arguments and test your speech against the clock.