Should Children Under 13 Have Smartphones?
Debate whether young children need phones for safety and learning or whether a smartphone-free childhood protects their development.
Pick a Side
Choose a position to defend, or let fate assign your stance.
Arguments FOR
1. Phones help parents keep children safe
Children who walk to school or attend activities alone can call home in an emergency and share their location.
2. Digital skills are essential
Learning to use technology responsibly from an early age prepares children for school and future jobs.
3. Being left out hurts
When classmates organise and chat on their phones, a child without one can feel excluded from friendships.
4. Parental controls reduce the risks
Modern phones let parents limit apps, set screen time and filter content, so a phone does not have to mean unlimited internet.
Arguments AGAINST
1. Smartphones disrupt sleep, attention and play
Writers such as Jonathan Haidt argue that phone-based childhood has replaced outdoor play and face-to-face friendship, harming mental health.
2. Young children are exposed to harmful content
Pornography, violence and predators can reach children even with filters in place.
3. A basic phone is enough for safety
Children can carry a simple phone that only calls and texts, without social media and endless apps.
4. Parents are uniting to delay phones
Movements such as Smartphone Free Childhood show that if families agree to wait together, children are not left out.
Counter Questions
Questions to challenge claims and probe deeper into trade-offs.
- What is the right age for a first smartphone, and what should decide it?
- Should schools ban phones entirely from the school day, including at break time?
- Is a smartwatch or basic phone a fair middle ground?
- If every friend has a phone, is it realistic for one family to say no?
- Should phone makers be required to sell child-safe versions by default?
Ready to debate this topic?
Prepare your arguments and test your speech against the clock.