Should Governments Cap Working Hours to Prevent Overwork?
Debate legal limits on overtime, from Japan's fight against karoshi to South Korea's 52-hour week.
Pick a Side
Choose a position to defend, or let fate assign your stance.
Arguments FOR
1. Overwork kills
Japan has a word, karoshi, for death from overwork, and the WHO and ILO have linked long working hours to hundreds of thousands of deaths a year.
2. Long hours do not mean more productivity
Tired workers make more mistakes, and productivity per hour often falls as hours rise.
3. Workers need protection from pressure
In competitive workplaces, employees feel unable to refuse overtime without legal limits.
4. Caps already exist
Japan introduced overtime caps in 2019, and South Korea set a 52-hour maximum week in 2018.
Arguments AGAINST
1. Some workers want more hours
Many people want overtime to earn more money.
2. Businesses need flexibility
Seasonal industries and start-ups need to work longer hours at busy times.
3. One rule does not fit every job
Doctors, farmers and creative professionals have very different working patterns.
4. Caps can push work off the books
Employees may work unpaid overtime from home to meet the same deadlines.
Counter Questions
Questions to challenge claims and probe deeper into trade-offs.
- What is the maximum number of hours a person should work in a week?
- Should the self-employed be covered by working-hour caps?
- Why did South Korea's 2023 proposal to allow up to 69 hours a week cause such a backlash?
- Is workplace culture a bigger problem than the law?
- Should employers be fined when employees work too much?
Ready to debate this topic?
Prepare your arguments and test your speech against the clock.