Skip to content
Debate Topics
Cross-Examination Guide

Debate Questions & Cross-Examination

Debates are won during cross-examination. These targeted questions help you probe evidence, challenge assumptions, and expose logical fallacies in your opponent's case.

Curated Debate Question Sets

Cross-Exam Ready
ai·medium

Should Governments Strictly Regulate Artificial Intelligence?

Q1:Can domestic AI regulations succeed without a binding, enforceable international treaty signed by all major powers?
Q2:How do regulators draw a clear line between high-risk frontier models and harmless open-source research?
Q3:Why did the European Union's comprehensive AI Act face fierce pushback from French and German tech entrepreneurs?
ai·hard

Should Fully Autonomous Lethal Weapons Be Banned by International Treaty?

Q1:How can an international treaty verify whether a drone's targeting software requires human confirmation or acts autonomously?
Q2:Does requiring 'meaningful human control' become meaningless if human operators simply rubber-stamp 100 computer targets per second?
Q3:Why did the International Committee of the Red Cross call for an urgent legally binding ban by 2026?
ai·medium

Should Creating Non-Consensual Deepfakes Be Classified as a Felony Crime?

Q1:How should criminal statutes carve out clear exemptions for Hollywood movie CGI, historical recreations, and satirical comedy?
Q2:Should social media platforms that host and algorithmically boost viral deepfakes share criminal liability with the original creator?
Q3:Why did the UK and multiple US states rush to pass criminal legislation explicitly targeting sexually explicit AI deepfakes?
ai·medium

Should Purely AI-Generated Art and Content Be Eligible for Copyright?

Q1:At what percentage of human digital touch-up and editing does an AI-assisted artwork become eligible for copyright?
Q2:Why did the US Copyright Office repeatedly reject copyright registration for AI-generated images like Théâtre D'opéra Spatial?
Q3:If AI art enters the public domain, will video game studios stop hiring human digital concept artists?
ai·hard

Should AI Companies Pay Royalties for Training Data Scraped from the Web?

Q1:Why did OpenAI and Apple sign multi-million dollar licensing deals with publishers like News Corp and Reddit if training is strictly 'fair use'?
Q2:If a human artist studies Picasso's style and paints in that style, why is that legal while AI training on Picasso is questioned?
Q3:Should websites have a universally enforceable 'robots.txt' legal standard that guarantees models cannot train on their text?
ai·medium

Should Romantic and Emotional Companion AI Chatbots Be Banned or Restricted?

Q1:Should companion apps be strictly prohibited from using aggressive monetization tactics like paid emotional unlocks or flirtation paywalls?
Q2:Why did thousands of users petition the Italian privacy regulator after Replika temporarily banned erotic AI conversation?
Q3:Could companion AI chatbots lead to declining human birth rates and marriage rates in developed countries?
ai·hard

Should Governments Impose a Mandatory Global Moratorium on AGI Development?

Q1:How would international inspectors verify that an underground server cluster in another country isn't secretly training frontier models?
Q2:What specific mathematical safety milestones would have to be proven before an AGI moratorium could be lifted?
Q3:Why did AI pioneer Geoffrey Hinton leave Google specifically to warn the public about the existential dangers of unchecked scaling?
ai·hard

Should Courts Ban Artificial Intelligence in Bail and Criminal Sentencing?

Q1:Why did ProPublica's famous investigation into the COMPAS bail algorithm spark nationwide outrage over algorithmic racism?
Q2:Can an algorithm ever be truly unbiased if it is trained on arrest records from a criminal justice system with documented racial disparities?
Q3:Should private tech companies be forced to open-source all algorithmic sentencing code used in public courts?
ai·easy

Should Students Be Allowed to Use AI Tools for School Homework?

Q1:How can teachers accurately assess student learning if traditional take-home written essays can be produced in 5 seconds by chatbots?
Q2:Should oral exams and in-class handwritten bluebook essays become the primary evaluation method in high schools and colleges?
Q3:At what grade level is a child old enough to use generative writing tools without stunting their natural language development?
ai·medium

Should Governments Mandate Cryptographic Watermarks on All AI-Generated Media?

Q1:Why did the Biden-Harris Executive Order on AI mandate watermarking for federal content while recognizing technical limitations?
Q2:Can hardware-level camera signing (attesting photon capture at the sensor level) solve digital provenance better than software watermarks?
Q3:How should platforms handle legitimate human photographs that have been subtly edited using AI background removal tools?
ai·hard

Should Artificial Intelligence Systems Be Legally Recognized as Patent Inventors?

Q1:Why did South Africa's patent office grant a patent naming the AI system DABUS as the inventor while the US and UK rejected it?
Q2:If an AI discovers a cure for Alzheimer's entirely on its own, should that drug be barred from patent protection and placed immediately in the public domain?
Q3:Who should be legally liable if an AI-invented product causes catastrophic harm or infringes on another company's patent?
ai·medium

Should Companies Be Restricted from Fully Replacing Customer Service Staff with AI?

Q1:Should companies be legally mandated to clearly state 'You are speaking with an AI assistant' at the start of every phone call?
Q2:Why did Klarna publicly boast that its AI assistant handles the workload of 700 full-time customer service agents?
Q3:What happens to developing economies like India and the Philippines if Western corporations offshore customer service to servers instead of people?
ai·hard

Should AI Diagnostic Systems Ever Be Allowed to Override Human Doctors?

Q1:If an AI detects a tumor that a doctor claims is harmless, should hospital policy require a mandatory second human opinion?
Q2:Why are medical malpractice insurance providers beginning to demand that physicians consult AI diagnostic tools before diagnosing?
Q3:How can medical boards prevent algorithmic bias against minority patients when training data comes predominantly from wealthy academic hospitals?

Frequently Asked Questions

How should you ask cross-examination questions in a debate round?

Ask closed, leading questions that require short factual answers rather than broad open-ended prompts. Never ask a question when you do not already know the answer.

What is the purpose of cross-examination (CX)?

Cross-examination clarifies unclear opponent points, exposes evidentiary weaknesses or contradictions, and lays the groundwork for your partner’s upcoming rebuttal speech.